Organizations today are rapidly adopting artificial intelligence (AI) by prioritizing specific “use cases” to swiftly realize business value. While this approach accelerates the integration of AI into operations, it raises a critical question: Are organizations inadvertently bypassing the traditional product management process, specifically the discovery phase, by jumping directly into solution mode?
Definitions:
- AI Use Case: A clearly defined scenario applying artificial intelligence to solve a specific business or operational challenge, typically outlined as: “We will use [AI method] to solve [business problem] to achieve [measurable outcome].” For example, using natural language processing (NLP) to automatically classify customer feedback and extract trends in real-time.
- Product Management Process: The structured lifecycle of transforming market problems into valuable, usable, and feasible solutions. This process generally includes strategy, discovery, delivery, and measurement and iteration.
- Discovery (within Product Management): The structured exploratory phase where product teams understand user problems, validate assumptions, and assess potential solutions before committing development resources. Effective discovery ensures teams solve the correct problems before building solutions.
How AI Use Cases Differ from Traditional Discovery
AI use cases typically start with a predefined technology or capability matched to a business challenge, emphasizing immediate solution orientation. In contrast, traditional discovery prioritizes deeply understanding user problems before identifying appropriate technologies. This difference is significant:
| AI Use Case Approach | Traditional Discovery Approach |
|---|---|
| Business-problem focused | User-problem focused |
| Solutions identified early | Solutions identified after exploration |
| Tech-centric validation | User-centric validation |
| Accelerates time-to-solution | Prioritizes validated, scalable solutions |
Pros and Cons of a Use Case-Led Approach
Pros:
- Quickly aligns AI investments with tangible business outcomes.
- Simplifies AI concepts for stakeholder buy-in.
- Accelerates experimentation and deployment cycles.
- Example: McKinsey’s AI use case library effectively demonstrates how AI can practically solve specific business challenges.
- Example: Amazon’s implementation of AI-driven recommendations demonstrates rapid alignment of AI solutions with business outcomes, significantly increasing sales revenue.
Cons:
- Risks developing solutions without thorough user validation, leading to potential misalignment.
- Limited scalability if AI solutions narrowly fit specific contexts without broader applicability.
- Risks technology-driven solutions searching for problems, rather than responding to validated market needs.
- Example: Early chatbot implementations frequently lacked user adoption because user interaction needs were not thoroughly researched beforehand.
- Example: IBM Watson’s ambitious AI projects sometimes struggled due to insufficient initial user validation, leading to significant costs without achieving anticipated adoption.
Pitfalls of Skipping Discovery
Neglecting traditional discovery can lead to substantial failures. Gartner Predicts 30% of Generative AI Projects Will Be Abandoned After Proof of Concept By End of 2025, often due to lack of initial user validation and insufficient market fit. Organizations frequently invest significantly in sophisticated AI models, only to discover later these solutions don’t solve actual user needs or achieve business goals effectively.
Three-Step Framework: Integrating AI Use Cases with Discovery
Step 1: Outcome Before Algorithm
Define clear, user-centric outcomes alongside your AI use cases. Ensure alignment with overarching business goals before committing to specific technologies.
Step 2: Pair Use Cases with Discovery Sprints
Conduct lean discovery sprints concurrently with AI solution development. This parallel approach validates assumptions and ensures the technology solves validated, critical user problems.
Step 3: Embed Product Managers in AI Teams
Involve experienced product managers in AI projects to maintain a balanced focus on user needs, market viability, and technical feasibility, ensuring long-term product success.
Conclusion
AI use cases present a compelling path to rapid innovation but should not replace disciplined discovery practices. By blending the strengths of both approaches, organizations can innovate faster while delivering meaningful, validated, and scalable AI-driven solutions.
#AI #ProductStrategy #CTO #CPO
bencoding 