Every product and engineering organization wrestles with obvious problems. Technical debt. Conflicting priorities. Underpowered infrastructure. Inefficient processes. Those are solvable with time, attention, and a bit of management maturity.
The harder problems are the invisible ones. The ones that warp decisions without anyone saying a word. The ones that produce outcomes nobody intended. These are driven by what I call aesthetic force. Aesthetic force is the unseen pull created by taste, culture, prestige, identity, and politics. It is the gravity field beneath a product organization that shapes what gets built, who gets heard, and what becomes “the way we do things.” It is not logical. It is not measurable. Yet it is incredibly powerful.
Aesthetic force is why teams ship features that do not matter. It is why leaders chase elegant architectures that never reach production. It is why organizations obsess over frameworks rather than outcomes. It is why a simple decision becomes a six week debate. It is taste dressed up as strategy.
If you do not understand aesthetic force, it will run your organization without your consent.
Below is how to spot it, how to avoid it when it becomes toxic, and the few cases when you should embrace it.
How To Identify Aesthetic Force
Aesthetic force reveals itself through behavior, not words. Look for these patterns.
1. The Team Loves the Work More Than the Result
When engineers argue passionately for a solution that adds risk, time, or complexity, not because the customer needs it but because it is “clean,” “pure,” or “the right pattern,” you are witnessing aesthetic force.
2. Prestige Projects Receive Irrational Protection
If a feature or platform strand gets defended with the same fervor as a personal reputation, someone’s identity is tied to it. They are protecting an aesthetic ideal rather than the truth of the market.
3. Process Shifts Without Actual Improvement
If a new methodology, tool, or workflow gains traction before it proves value, you are watching aesthetic force in action. People are choosing the thing that looks modern or elite.
4. You Hear Phrases That Signal Taste Over Impact
“Elegant.”
“Beautiful.”
“Clean.”
“We should do it the right way.”
“When we rewrite it the right way.”
Any time you hear “right way” without specificity, aesthetic force is speaking.
5. Decisions Drift Toward What the Loudest Experts Prefer
Aesthetic force often hides behind seniority. If the organization defaults to the preferences of one influential architect or PM without evidence, the force is winning.
What To Do To Avoid Aesthetic Force Taking Over
Aesthetic force itself is not bad. Unchecked, it is destructive. You avoid that through intentional leadership.
1. Anchor Everything to Measurable Impact
Every debate should be grounded in a measurable outcome. If someone proposes a new pattern, integration, rewrite, or workflow, the burden of proof is on them to show how it improves speed, quality, reliability, or client experience.
Opinions are welcome. Impact determines direction.
2. Make Tradeoffs Explicit
Aesthetic force thrives in ambiguity. When you turn decisions into explicit tradeoffs, the fog clears.
Example:
Option A is more elegant but will delay us eight weeks. Option B is less elegant but gets us to market before busy season, improves adoption, and unblocks another team.
Elegance loses unless it delivers value.
3. Demand Evidence Before Evangelism
If someone champions a new tool, standard, or strategy, require a working example, a pilot, or a small-scale win. No more slideware revolutions.
4. Reward Shipping Over Posturing
Promote leaders who deliver outcomes, not theory. Teams emulate what they see rewarded. If prestige attaches to execution rather than aesthetic purity, the organization rebalances itself.
5. Break Identity Attachment
If someone’s identity is fused with a product, codebase, or architecture, rotate responsibilities or pair them with a peer reviewer. Aesthetic force is strongest when people believe their reputation depends on decisions staying a certain way.
When To Accept Aesthetic Force
There are rare moments when you should allow aesthetic force to influence the product. Doing so without awareness is reckless. Doing so intentionally can be powerful.
1. When You Are Establishing Product Taste
Every great product has an opinionated aesthetic at its core. Some teams call this product feel. Others call it craftsmanship. When aesthetics drive coherence, speed, and clarity, the force is working in your favor.
2. When the Aesthetic Attracts and Retains Exceptional Talent
Some technical choices create a virtuous cycle. A beautiful architecture can inspire great developers to join or stay. A well crafted experience can rally designers and PMs. Occasionally, embracing aesthetic force elevates the culture.
3. When It Becomes a Strategic Differentiator
If aesthetic excellence creates client trust, increases adoption, or reduces friction, it becomes a strategic tool. Apple’s product aesthetic is not a luxury. It is part of its moat.
4. When Shipping Fast Would Create Long Term Chaos
Sometimes the shortcut buries you later. Aesthetic force is useful when it protects you from reckless short term thinking. The key is to treat it as a conscious decision, not a reflex.
Thought
Aesthetic force is not a harmless quirk. It is a silent operator that will hijack your roadmap, distort your priorities, and convince smart people to pour months into work that has no strategic value. Leaders who ignore it end up managing an organization that behaves irrationally while believing it is acting with discipline.
If you want a product team that delivers results instead of beautiful distractions, you cannot treat aesthetic force as a background influence. You must surface it, confront it, and regulate it. When you do, the organization becomes sharper, faster, and far more honest about what matters. When you do not, aesthetic force becomes the real head of product, and it will not care about your clients, your deadlines, or your strategy.
The gravity is already pulling. Strong leaders decide the direction.
#ProductStrategy #EngineeringCulture #ProductThinking #CTO #CIO
bencoding 